The ERP vs. ERM Dilemma: Why Risk, Compliance, and Audit Practitioners Need to Reframe the Conversation

In South Africa, the eagerness to invest in ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) systems over ERM (Enterprise Risk Management) is deeply connected to the sectors that dominate the economy and how they operate. Key industries like mining, manufacturing, retail, agriculture, and logistics not only form the backbone of the economy but also heavily influence business operations in other sectors.

---

Here’s the connection:

Dominance of large, resource-industries:

Industries such as mining, manufacturing, and agriculture are cornerstone sectors of the South African economy. These sectors rely on complex supply chains, significant asset management, and large-scale resource planning to maintain operations. ERP systems are essential in such environments because they integrate diverse operations like procurement, inventory management, financial accounting, and human resources into one cohesive platform. The need for efficient resource allocation and optimization in these sectors naturally drives demand for ERP solutions.

Focus on efficiency and operational optimization:

South Africa’s dominant sectors are capital-intensive and focus heavily on operational efficiency. Mining and manufacturing, for example, rely on ERP systems to track production, manage supply chains, control costs, and maintain real-time operational visibility. These industries prioritize tools that ensure they can operate at scale while minimizing inefficiencies, making ERP systems a critical part of their business strategy. Given that these industries account for a substantial portion of the economy, the focus on ERP in these sectors creates a trickle-down effect. Other industries that support mining, manufacturing, and logistics, such as financial services, IT, and retail, also adopt ERP systems to stay aligned with the operational needs of their largest clients. This leads to a cyclical demand for ERP systems across various industries.

Integration with supply chain and logistics needs:

South Africa’s economy is highly reliant on logistics and transportation to support both domestic and international trade. ERP systems are essential for tracking inventory, managing suppliers, and ensuring smooth operations across the supply chain. As major industries require seamless integration from suppliers, distributors, and partners, these auxiliary businesses need to adopt ERP systems to meet the demands of larger clients.

For instance, the retail sector, which is heavily influenced by the mining and manufacturing sectors, uses ERP systems to manage inventory, streamline ordering processes, and optimize supply chains. When ERP systems are integrated across sectors, they create a cycle of demand: suppliers and service providers need ERP systems to communicate effectively with larger ERP-enabled clients, further increasing ERP adoption across the economy.

Regulatory compliance and standardization:

ERP systems help large sectors comply with regulatory standards and ensure standardization across multiple functions (financial reporting, tax compliance, and supply chain visibility). This becomes especially important in sectors like mining, manufacturing, and logistics, where regulatory compliance is critical. As these sectors push for compliance, the supporting industries adopt ERP systems to align with the same standards, thereby reinforcing the need for ERP solutions across the economy.

Trickle-down effect on SMEs:

Many SMMEs (small and medium-sized enterprises) in South Africa that supply to larger companies in mining, agriculture, or manufacturing sectors face pressures to optimize their operations and integrate with larger supply chains. These SMMEs may not have the resources for full-scale ERP systems initially, but as they grow and seek to streamline operations, they increasingly adopt ERP systems. The operational demands of larger industries create a cycle where more and more businesses—large and small—adopt ERP systems to stay competitive and efficient.

The Disconnect: Why ERM systems are overlooked

Despite the clear value of ERM, companies are often reluctant to invest in it. Here’s why:

1. Perception of ERM as a compliance tool:

   
   

   Many businesses view ERM systems as a way to simply avoid fines or meet regulatory requirements, rather than as a tool to enhance business resilience and strategic decision-making.

   
   

2. Lack of direct ROI:

   
   

   Unlike ERP, which offers immediate operational improvements, ERM's value can be harder to quantify. Risk mitigation often prevents potential future losses, making it difficult to justify the investment without a direct and visible return.

   
   

3. Siloed approach to risk:

   
   

   Many organizations treat risk management as a separate function, isolated from core business operations. This separation reduces its perceived importance compared to systems like ERP, which touch every part of the business.

For an Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) system to provide the same level of value as an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system in the current technology landscape, it would need to evolve beyond its traditional focus on risk mitigation and compliance. The system must integrate more directly into the daily operations of the business and demonstrate clear operational benefits and ROI.

Here’s how an ERM system could achieve that:

Integration with core business functions

To match the value of ERP systems, an ERM platform should be deeply integrated with core business functions like finance, procurement, HR, supply chain management, and operations. This would allow risk management to be part of the daily operational workflow, not just a separate governance process.

• Financial Integration: Connect risk indicators directly to financial outcomes. For example, if a certain risk—such as a supplier delay—could lead to increased costs or lost revenue, the ERM system would flag these risks in the financial dashboard, linking them to potential profit and loss impacts.

  
  

• Operational Risk Alerts: If there are risks related to production delays, equipment failures, or employee turnover, the system should notify relevant departments immediately and provide recommendations on how to address them within the operational systems.

Data-Driven decision making and Predictive Analytics

ERM systems should harness AI and machine learning to analyze vast amounts of data from across the organization and predict potential risks before they materialize. Just as ERP systems track inventory and resources, ERM could continuously monitor for emerging risks, like compliance issues, cybersecurity threats, or market changes, and forecast their potential impact on business operations.

• Risk Prediction Models: Develop sophisticated algorithms that forecast risks based on historical data, industry trends, and external factors such as regulatory changes, economic conditions, and even social events. These models could proactively suggest mitigation strategies that link directly to business functions, enabling decision-makers to act on insights before risks escalate.

  
  

• Scenario Simulations: Allow companies to simulate various risk scenarios (e.g., supply chain disruption, regulatory changes) and analyze their potential impact on operations, helping to justify risk mitigation efforts with clear, data-backed insights.

Real-Time monitoring and Reporting

Just like ERP systems provide real-time views of operations, ERM systems should offer real-time monitoring of risk factors and automatically generate reports that tie back to business performance metrics. For example:

• Custom Dashboards: ERM systems should include dynamic dashboards that provide real-time updates on the risk environment of various business units, such as supply chain, HR, or finance. Users should be able to track KPIs related to risk management, and the system should highlight deviations from acceptable risk levels.

  
  

• Automated Reporting: Generate reports on risks across all operational areas in real-time, integrating them with other performance reports that are traditionally available in ERP systems. For instance, if there’s a compliance breach or potential supplier failure, the ERM system should automatically notify key stakeholders and provide options for mitigating the issue.

Proactive risk management embedded in daily tasks

An ERM system should not just react to risks but embed proactive risk management into the day-to-day operations of a business. For instance:

• Task-Level Risk Tracking: When employees engage in daily tasks—like managing contracts, conducting procurement, or handling logistics—the system could automatically scan these activities for risk flags. For example, if a contract lacks sufficient protections or a supplier is facing financial instability, the ERM system would alert the user.

  
  

• Automated Risk Mitigation Plans: After identifying risks, the system should suggest mitigation steps and assign tasks to the relevant employees, much like how an ERP system handles procurement or production tasks. The focus here would be to integrate risk management into daily workflows, rather than treating it as an isolated governance function.

Cost and compliance savings

To deliver tangible ROI, an ERM system must help businesses save money by avoiding costs linked to non-compliance, operational disruptions, and unmitigated risks. This could be achieved through features such as:

• Automated Compliance Monitoring: ERP systems often help companies streamline finances and operations, and ERM systems should offer the same value by automating compliance monitoring. This would involve tracking all industry regulations, local laws, and company policies in real-time and flagging areas of concern before they lead to costly penalties.

  
  

• Compliance Cost Reduction: By automatically updating businesses on changing regulations and compliance requirements, the system could help reduce legal and compliance costs. This would help businesses maintain certifications, avoid penalties, and ensure that all operational areas are compliant without the need for manual oversight.

Mobile and cloud-based accessibility

Much like ERP systems, which often offer cloud-based platforms that allow employees to access data from anywhere, ERM systems should leverage the cloud to provide mobile-friendly risk management tools.

• Mobile Risk Management: Employees on the ground—whether in manufacturing plants, logistics operations, or customer service—should be able to log risks, track incidents, and receive alerts in real-time from their mobile devices. This ensures that risk management is integrated into every operational level, regardless of location.

  
  

• Cloud-Based Collaboration: ERM should allow various departments to collaborate on risk mitigation efforts seamlessly. For instance, operations, legal, and finance teams should be able to share real-time data and collaborate on addressing compliance or operational risks, with all stakeholders having visibility over the process.

Customization and flexibility

To match the adaptability of ERP systems, an ERM system should be highly customizable to suit the specific needs of different industries. Whether a company is in logistics, manufacturing, or retail, the ERM system should offer tailored tools for:

• Industry-Specific Risks: Manufacturing might need a focus on supply chain risks, while finance may need deeper compliance and regulatory tracking. The system should allow for customization based on sector-specific risk factors and integrate relevant risk frameworks (e.g., COSO, ISO 31000) that suit the industry’s needs.

  
  

• Scalability: Similar to ERP systems, ERM platforms must be scalable, allowing small businesses to grow into the system without needing to switch platforms. As businesses expand, the ERM system should accommodate additional departments, new compliance needs, and more complex risk scenarios.

The Real Value of ERM: Risk, Compliance, and Audit Practitioners’ Perspective

To convince boards and executives to take ERM systems more seriously, practitioners need to reposition ERM as a strategic asset rather than just a compliance tool.

Here’s how to approach the conversation:

Highlight the integration potential of ERM with core business functions

Just like ERP systems, ERM can integrate with core business functions, allowing for real-time risk tracking across finance, procurement, HR, and operations. By linking risk management to operational outcomes, businesses can make more informed decisions that improve not only compliance but also profitability. For instance, financial risks can be tied directly to cash flow projections, helping the company avoid sudden shortfalls. Supply chain risks can be monitored and mitigated in real-time, preventing costly disruptions that could arise during key operational periods.

Leverage Predictive Analytics and Data-Driven Decision Making

With the rise of AI and machine learning, ERM systems are no longer just passive tools for documentation. They offer predictive capabilities that allow businesses to forecast potential risks and act on them before they escalate into full-blown crises.

For example, predictive analytics can forecast risks like supplier failures, regulatory changes, or even cybersecurity threats based on historical data and real-time market analysis. These insights are actionable and can be used to steer business decisions, aligning risk management with the company’s broader strategic objectives.

 Demonstrate cost savings through compliance and risk reduction

Though ERM systems may not show the same immediate cost reductions as ERP systems, the long-term savings from avoided fines, lawsuits, and operational disruptions can be substantial. Compliance with local laws, international standards (such as ISO 31000 or COSO), and industry regulations can safeguard a company’s financial stability and reputation.

For example, a logistics company that invests in ERM can avoid costly accidents by complying with the National Road Traffic Act and SANS standards related to dangerous goods transport which could effect the premiums paid for on insurance and claims. This avoids penalties and enhances the company’s operational safety during high-demand periods like the festive season.

Emphasize real-time Monitoring and reporting

ERP systems are prized for their ability to provide real-time views of operations. ERM systems can offer the same value through real-time monitoring of compliance, operational risk, and even cybersecurity vulnerabilities. These real-time insights allow for quick adjustments that keep the company running smoothly, even in times of high demand or regulatory uncertainty.

For example, during peak periods, a logistics company could use an ERM system to monitor vehicle compliance and driver safety standards in real-time, preventing potential delays caused by non-compliance.

What to Look For in an ERM System

Integrate with ERP systems

An ERM system that seamlessly integrates with existing ERP platforms is crucial. This ensures that risk data is connected to operational outcomes, making risk management part of the broader business strategy.

Provides real-time reporting and analytics:

Choose a system that offers real-time dashboards and automated reporting to ensure compliance and risk data are constantly up-to-date and visible to all stakeholders.

Supports predictive risk models:

Look for systems that leverage AI and predictive analytics to identify emerging risks, helping the business to stay proactive rather than reactive.

Offers customization:

Every business faces unique risks. Ensure that the ERM system is customizable to your industry and operational requirements, whether you're in logistics, manufacturing, or retail.

Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) should not be seen as a secondary consideration to Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. By integrating ERM into the core business strategy, leveraging data-driven insights, and showcasing long-term cost savings, risk practitioners can shift the focus of executives and boards. This will help to unlock more budget, allowing businesses to invest in modern, sophisticated ERM solutions that not only ensure compliance but also foster business growth, continuity, and resilience.